Skip to main content

Oliver Twist 2023 - Part 3

Parts One and Two of this series dealt with the history of child labor in America and what has changed over the past 200 years. 


My sisters and I worked from the time we hit pre-teen until we retired.  We always wanted things that our family budget couldn’t cover, so making my own money was the way I paid for my first pair of contacts, a new winter coat that I really didn’t need, or a haircut from a professional rather than my mother.  Our jobs covered the spectrum:  babysitting, hospital aide, salesperson, office assistant, waitressing.  These jobs taught us to handle money, work with people, and manage time.  These skills were a keystone to my somewhat successful life. 

Nobody argues that children benefit from work experience, as long as it is overseen by parents, state law, and decent employers.  

So why are laws that protect children in the workforce changing in 2023, particularly in Republican states ?

Since Part 2 of this series, Iowa Governor Kim Reynolds stated that she will sign a bill into law that will roll back labor protections for children by allowing them to work longer hours at jobs that had previously been prohibited, according to the Washington Post.  And Wisconsin legislators introduced a bill that allows children 14 and younger to serve alcohol in restaurants. 

Other states are considering loosening child labor restrictions, citing parents who approve of their children’s employment and voters who want to limit federal laws.  Promoted by conservative groups mentioned in Parts 1 and 2 and employers looking for cheap labor in an ever-dwindling workforce, children seem to be the answer to Republican’s prayers. 

This comes after the U.S. Labor Department announced last Tuesday that it discovered two 10-year-old children working at McDonald’s in Louisville, Kentucky.  And they sometimes labored until 2 in the morning, according to Vox News.  As a retired teacher, I know what this does to a student’s ability to focus in the classroom. 

Also, according to Vox, the Labor Department’s budget is now operating with less funding and 12% fewer staff since 2010.  The department’s Office of the Solicitor has lost more than 100 attorneys over the past 10 years, also due to budget cuts.  So organizations like the Foundation for Government Accountability, the Cato Institute, the Koch brothers, and now politicians can move to change the child labor laws with limited push-back from the Labor Department.  Maybe the Republican effort to defund the government isn’t just about supporting individual freedom, but also about exploiting child workers.

Keep a few things in mind:  rich kids don’t generally have after school jobs, so this new work force being exploited by the right comes from poor and working-class families.  And that demographic is growing, making this a rich source of labor - cheap labor.  Migrant children have always been employed in agriculture; these new rules make children as young as 14 legal for dangerous construction and meat-packing jobs. 

But, as always with 21st century Republicans, there seems to be some blatant hypocrisy afoot.

For example, how can a party that aligns itself entirely with the rights of an unborn child, even to the extent of harming or killing the mother, be okay with a child that labors in unsafe working conditions for unlimited hours ?  Maybe being anti-abortion now means being pro-child labor ?  But maybe I do see the connection.  If more children are born, well then, that increases your work pool, doesn’t it ?

And this conservative party says it cares so much about what children read that it bans books in droves, making sure that no child is exposed to an idea the party doesn’t support.  So how can this same group be okay with a child working long hours and jeopardizing her ability to learn to read all those banned books ?  Hmm…but maybe that’s it.  If kids can’t read, then Republicans don’t have to worry about banning any more books, a highly unpopular idea anyway.  An added plus is that this increases illiteracy in the voter pool, making the electorate more susceptible to misinformation from the right. 

Finally, how can a party that cares so much about the autonomy of parents on issues like social media, school curriculum, and Disney take away the right of parents to give consent when their child applies for a job, as proposed in several red state legislatures and just signed into law in Arkansas ?  Maybe it’s because parental rights don’t matter that much when bumping up against the demand for cheap labor by the captains of industry. 

The Republican party cares about three things:  money, its wealthy constituents who fuel campaigns, and power.  Period. It’s a party that lives and will eventually die by the mantra that money trickles down and one must feed the powerful corporations, not the hungry. 

In Virginia, the state code regulates the number of hours, days, and jobs a child can work during school and in the summer.  You can check the specifications by age and legality of jobs for child laborers at this address:

These are good laws:  we need to vote for democrats to keep them that way. 


Thus, it is vital to stand up and speak out in any way we can.  We need to Roar Like McMorrow !

Do something and anything to help us win both houses of the Virginia General Assembly and put a stop to MAGA and Youngkin:


Popular posts from this blog

Jane’s Dilemma - Part 1

Our girl Jane just finished a four-year degree program, graduating with honors in front of beaming parents who proudly watched their only daughter receive her diploma.  Unfortunately, the day after graduation, Jane discovered that all of her fears were right and she was, indeed, pregnant. Her boyfriend of the past several months had accepted a job on the other side of the country. He shouted promises that they’d stay in touch over his shoulder as he ran to catch his flight. Jane was pretty sure they wouldn’t, just like she was pretty sure her parents wouldn’t continue beaming if she told them the news. Jane looked at the three letters of interest from companies she longed to work for, lined in a row on her desk. They had made her jubilant about her future just a week ago, before she began to suspect the truth. She wondered how much interest any of these potential employers would garner if she arrived, breathless with enthusiasm and obviously pregnant. Jane twirled a wrinkled, white car

Roar Like McMorrow

 Just over a year ago this happened: Michigan Senator Mallory McMorrow gave a powerful speech that went viral and was an inspiration for many progressives including myself. At that time, I had just retired as a health care provider for under-served members of our community and I knew I needed to get involved.  This speech kicked my rear end into gear so I joined the Staunton Democratic Committee. So what was so special about her speech ? There have been many individuals and communities in history that have stood up, spoke out, pushed back and bent but did not break.  This speech and her message of tolerance and caring for others while exposing and pushing back against the hatred and hypocrisy of others hit me at just the right time.  I had never heard of Mallory McMorrow but I will never forget that transformative moment.    All of us have had those moments where something happens to shift our thinking, pushes us into action and makes us a better person.  Also, we have all been the sou

Sound the alarm and woke up !

If you’ve turned on the TV recently, you’ve probably heard some politician talking about being “woke,” while sporting an expression that looks like he just swallowed castor oil. So what is this “woke” stuff, you ask ? Woke is the past tense of the verb to wake, and in my opinion, it beats the alternative in any case. If you don’t wake up in the morning, then you sleep through the day; if you don’t wake up from a day dream, you probably slept through the last meeting you attended. And if you don’t wake up from an operation, well, we all know what that means. So why is being “woke” so bad for those on the right ? It isn’t, unless you’re a Republican in bad need of a mantra that will get you re-elected by constituents who haven’t, well, waked up to what’s happening in this country. “If woke ideology takes over, it will destroy this country. We are not going to let that happen in the state of Florida,” said Ron DeSantis in a recent speech to his constituents. Let’s dig into that. The g